• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Sal & Al's Diner - Amherst, OH: Cozy Spot for Fresh Salads, Burgers & Comfort Food

Sal & Al's Diner in Amherst, Ohio, is a charming, welcoming spot known for its diverse and satisfying menu. From the flavorful Smashburger and classic burgers to fresh gyro salads featuring crispy flatbread croutons, each dish is crafted with care. Guests praise the kid-friendly buttered noodles and comforting options like meat pies and chicken paprikas. The atmosphere is clean and cozy, making it ideal for family meals or casual visits. Quick, attentive service further enhances the experience. Sal & Al's offers great value—a warm, hearty meal comparable in price to fast food but with the quality and comfort of a true neighborhood diner.

Sal & Al's Diner - Amherst, OH at a glance

  • Address 2261 Cooper Foster Park Rd, Amherst, OH 44001, United States
  • Phone +1 440-989-3663
  • Restaurant type Diner , Pizza restaurant .
  • Popular for Popular for breakfast , Popular for lunch , Popular for dinner , Good for solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

Sal & Al's Diner - Amherst, OH: Reviews & Ratings

Lenny Oehlke
5

I was initially going to a sandwich shop located in the same plaza. I just wanted something quick to take home. After waiting for far too long in that shop I walked out. Strolled down to Sal & Al's. They sat me quickly. Took my order just as fast. I had the Smashburger and fries. The price for a warm meal in a nice restaurant was about the same as I would have paid for a sub. I recommend this place!!!

Alex Young
5

Cute little place with an interesting selection of food. My kids loved their buttered noodles and I thoroughly enjoyed my meat pies.

Stephanie Woodings
5

We've been aware of this little nook of a restaurant for quite some time and we always say, "We gotta try this place." Well today we stopped, and we were pleasantly surprised! I had the gyro salad and the hubster had the classic burger, but there are a multitude of menu items. My salad was SO fresh and yummy and the gyro meat was excellent. The croutons on top of the salad were actually small bits of flatbread that had been deep fried. Wow! Took half of the salad home! My hubby enjoyed every bit of his burger and we both agreed we would be back.

Steven Szurgot
5

Another great visit to Sal & Als never disappoints Food & Service were excellent i come from Akron and will keep coming. I had read some of the negative reviews and although no place is perfect some of the comments were extreme The Atmosphere is great and the restaurant is very clean Keep doing what you do so happy for you and your new adventure. See you soon!!

FeyaAmante
5

My first time dining here. I had the Syrian salad with the addition of gyro meat, chicken was another option. I enjoyed the salad. I was there with a small group. One ordered a BLT, one a pizza, one the perogies, and two the chicken paprikas. Everyone was happy with their meals. The service was good.

Amy Palazzola
5

Went to Sal & Al's with some friends last week. We tried the deep dish pizza. By far, the BEST deep dish we've ever had. Their sauce is absolutely amazing. Our server, Melissa, was super attentive and fun. Will definitely request to be seated in her section again. And, if you have a sweet tooth, it is worth noting that the ice cream shop includes both sugar free & vegan options. The peanut butter overload did not disappoint.

Location

  • Sal & Al's Diner - Amherst, OH
    Sal & Al's Diner - Amherst, OH
    2261 Cooper Foster Park Rd, Amherst, OH 44001, United States Hotline: +1 440-989-3663

Sal & Al's Diner in Amherst, OH, is a charming spot that brings the classic diner experience with a distinctive twist. Nestled at 2261 Cooper Foster Park Rd, this eatery offers a varied menu that masterfully blends traditional comfort foods with bold, inventive flavors. From the moment you step inside, you sense the care poured into each dish, a sentiment echoed by many loyal patrons. The diner’s highlight dishes like the Gyro, with tender, flavorful meat that elevates the fresh Syrian salad, and the signature diner burgers — especially the Cajun Burger and Big Texan BBQ Burger — showcase a balance of hearty, savory richness and satisfying textures.

The Pierogi Pizza and Fold Over Pizza bring a playful twist to classic pizza offerings, merging cultural favorites into something both familiar and exciting. The Chicken Paprikash Dinner stands out as a comforting, home-style option, full of aromatic paprika and tender chicken that warms the soul. For those craving crispy, indulgent sides, the Mac Attack Burger paired with onion rings or the Burger and Bacon Cheesy Fries deliver bold, savory bites that linger pleasantly long after the meal.

What truly makes Sal & Al's stand apart is its ability to cater to diverse tastes without sacrificing quality. Whether you’re here for the Bone-In Chicken Wings, the Patty Melt, or a light Grilled Chicken Salad, each plate tells a story of thoughtful preparation and authentic diner charm. The atmosphere is inviting and clean, making it a perfect refuge for a quick bite or a relaxed family dinner. Customer experiences highlight the attentive service and the surprising depth of flavor in every meal, reinforcing that Sal & Al's is more than just a neighborhood diner — it’s a true culinary find in Amherst.

In my visits, the gyro salad impressed me with its fresh ingredients and the delightful texture contrast of fried flatbread croutons. The Smashburger, simple yet satisfying, reminded me why classic diner fare remains timeless. Overall, Sal & Al's nails the balance between comfort and creativity, crafting dishes that satisfy hunger and curiosity alike. For anyone in northeastern Ohio seeking a reliable spot with vibrant flavors and hearty meals, Sal & Al’s Diner is a must-visit destination.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Has wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
    • Has wheelchair-accessible seating
    • Has wheelchair-accessible toilet
  • Service options
    • On-site services available
    • Offers takeaway
    • Serves dine-in
    • Delivery
  • Payments
    • Accepts credit cards
    • Accepts debit cards
    • Accepts NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards